Supreme Court to Review President’s Questions on Governor Powers, Article 142 Scope

Last Updated Jul - 22 - 2025, 02:56 PM | Source : Fela news

A Constitution Bench led by CJI BR Gavai will examine President Murmu’s reference on timelines for Governors and the use of Article 142, with implications for a

Supreme Court to Review President’s Questions

On Tuesday, July 22, 2025, a Constitution Bench led by Chief Justice of India (CJI) B.R. Gavai noted that the constitutional questions raised by President Droupadi Murmu regarding whether timelines can be imposed on the President and Governors when reviewing State legislation are of national significance. The five-judge Bench, which includes Justices Surya Kant, Vikram Nath, P.S. Narasimha, and A.S. Chandurkar, decided to hear the matter in mid-August, around Independence Day.

The court issued notices to all State governments and the Centre, seeking their responses within a week. CJI Gavai clarified that all issues in the Presidential Reference would remain open for consideration.

The Reference, issued on May 13, invokes Article 143 of the Constitution, seeking the Supreme Court’s advisory opinion. It broadly asks whether judicial intervention can impose deadlines on constitutional functions of the President and Governors under Articles 200 and 201, which deal with the assent to State Bills and the reservation of Bills for Presidential consideration.

The move follows a controversial Supreme Court ruling on April 8, where a two-judge Bench held the Tamil Nadu Governor’s delay in processing 10 re-passed Bills as unconstitutional. The court had invoked Article 142 to declare that all 10 Bills had received assent, prompting criticism and concern over judicial overreach into executive functions.

Senior advocate K.K. Venugopal, representing Kerala, questioned the maintainability of the Presidential Reference. Tamil Nadu’s counsel, P. Wilson, argued that the April 8 verdict already addressed the President’s questions. However, CJI Gavai emphasized that the matter involved all States and required broader scrutiny.

The Reference questions whether the President or Governors’ powers under Articles 200 and 201 can be subject to court-imposed timelines and whether the judiciary can direct the manner in which these powers are exercised. It also challenges whether the Supreme Court can substitute executive powers through Article 142 and asks whether "deemed assent" — as invoked in the Tamil Nadu case — fits within constitutional limits.

Further, the Reference raises doubts about whether actions under Articles 200 and 201 can be challenged in court before a Bill becomes law, and whether courts can intervene in matters related to a Bill's content pre-enactment.

Vice-President Jagdeep Dhankhar had earlier described Article 142 as a "nuclear missile" against democratic institutions. The Supreme Court, however, defended its use of the provision, stating it was applied after deep deliberation and in public interest to address clear constitutional violations by the Governor.

The Reference also questions the legality of a two-judge Bench ruling on significant constitutional issues without referring the matter to a Constitution Bench, as required under Article 145(3).

Moreover, the Reference revisits basic interpretations of Article 200, such as the scope of a Governor’s discretion, the extent to which they are bound by the State Cabinet’s advice, and whether Article 361, which grants immunity to the President and Governors, bars judicial scrutiny of their actions under Article 200.

The April 8 ruling had firmly stated that Governors must act within a reasonable time and follow Cabinet advice, reinforcing the democratic principle that legislative processes reflect the will of the people.

Trending this week

Delhi Police Arrest Wanted Criminal Khemchand After Gunfight in Ghazipur

Jul - 22 - 2025

Delhi Police apprehended a notorious criminal after a brief shootout in the Ghazipur area of east Delhi, officials reported on Tuesday, July 22, 20... Read More

NASA-ISRO's NISAR Earth Observation Satellite to Launch on July 30 from Sriharikota

Jul - 22 - 2025

The NASA-ISRO Synthetic Aperture Radar (NISAR), the first collaborative satellite developed by the U.S. and Indian space agencies, is scheduled for... Read More

Public Hearing in Bihar Demands Cancellation of SIR Amid Voter Disenfranchisement Concerns

Jul - 22 - 2025

On Monday, July 21, 2025, several people's organisations and movements in Bihar held a day-long public hearing in Patna to address growing concerns... Read More

DGCA Issues 9 Show-Cause Notices to Air India Amid Decline in Overall Airline Penalties

Jul - 22 - 2025

The Directorate General of Civil Aviation (DGCA) has issued nine show-cause notices to Air India over five safety-related violations in the past si... Read More

Heavy Rains Lash Delhi, Cause Waterlogging and Traffic Delays; IMD Predicts More Showers

Jul - 22 - 2025

Delhi experienced a heavy spell of rain on Tuesday morning, bringing much-needed relief from the heat but causing waterlogging and traffic disrupti... Read More

Vice President Dhankhar Resigns Citing Health Reasons, Sparks Political Speculation

Jul - 22 - 2025

The sudden resignation of Vice President Jagdeep Dhankhar on Monday evening has stirred political circles nationwide, catching both the BJP and the... Read More

Supreme Court to Review President’s Questions on Governor Powers, Article 142 Scope

Supreme Court to Review President’s Questions on Governor Powers, Article 142 Scope

Trending this week

Get Connect

Explore

Education

Contact

Newsletter